Michele Collins & Paige Tiller
After Michele decided to close the doors on her embroidery business and Paige retired from teaching preschool, the two wanted to come together on a new venture — and Fancy Finds SSI was born. A thoughtfully curated online boutique, it blends modern elegance with laid-back coastal charm — offering a refined collection of home goods, gifts, and lifestyle accessories. While many island boutiques lean on anchors, shells, and tropes, Fancy Finds SSI emphasizes simplicity, sophistication, and distinctive products that feel timeless and well-chosen, setting itself apart from the sea of coastal kitsch.
As a mother-daughter team, we believe shopping should feel personal, inspiring, and full of delight. Whether you're looking for the perfect hostess gift, a little something for yourself, or a keepsake to remember your trip to the island, you'll find it here at Fancy Finds SSI.
Our mission is to offer beautiful, thoughtfully curated pieces that inspire joy, reflect refined simplicity, and bring calm elegance into everyday life — rooted in the charm of St. Simons Island, without the predictable coastal motifs.
So shop our collections to discover our newest finds—there’s always something special waiting for you.
